Marry Me Chicken Sushi Cups

I discovered these little golden cups while scrolling through cooking videos at midnight, mesmerized by how the creamy chicken mixture held its shape in muffin tins like edible treasure. The concept felt ridiculous at first—sushi bake meets comfort food meets fancy appetizer—but something about the mashup intrigued me enough to grab a muffin tin the next morning. When they came out of the oven, golden and fragrant with garlic and sun-dried tomatoes, I understood the appeal instantly. They're crispy on top, creamy inside, and somehow feel both indulgent and elegant without requiring years of culinary training.

I brought these to a dinner party where someone had just gotten engaged, and watching everyone's faces as they took that first bite made the whole experiment feel worthwhile. The combination of crispy panko, tender chicken, and that silky sauce somehow sparked a conversation about fusion cooking and how the best food happens when you stop taking recipes too seriously. One guest asked for the recipe before dessert even arrived, which I took as the highest compliment possible.

Ingredients

• Cooked orzo pasta: This small, rice-shaped pasta absorbs the creamy sauce beautifully without becoming mushy, and it's sturdy enough to hold the cups together when baked.
• Cooked chicken breast: Shred or dice it small so every bite gets that tender protein; rotisserie chicken saves time and adds subtle smokiness.
• Heavy cream: Don't substitute with light cream or half-and-half or the sauce becomes too thin and the cups lose their cohesion during baking.
• Grated Parmesan cheese: Buy a block and grate it yourself if possible—pre-grated cheese contains anti-caking agents that can make the sauce grainy.
• Sun-dried tomatoes: Chop them fine so they distribute evenly; their tangy sweetness balances the richness of the cream and prevents the dish from feeling one-dimensional.
• Fresh basil: Add it at the very end so it keeps its bright flavor rather than turning bitter when baked.
• Eggs: These act as a binder, helping the mixture set firm in the muffin cups without becoming dense.
• Panko breadcrumbs: The larger crumbs stay crispier than regular breadcrumbs, creating that satisfying textural contrast.

Instructions

Prepare your stage:

Preheat the oven to 375°F and lightly spray your muffin tin so the finished cups slide out cleanly. Have your cooked orzo and chicken ready before you start the sauce, as timing matters here.

Build the Marry Me sauce:

Warm olive oil in a skillet and let the minced garlic soften for just a minute—you want fragrant, not browned. Pour in the heavy cream and let it bubble gently while you add the Parmesan, sun-dried tomatoes, Italian herbs, red pepper flakes, salt, and pepper, stirring until the sauce thickens slightly and smells absolutely incredible.

Marry the chicken:

Fold the shredded chicken into the warm sauce and let it sit off heat for a minute so the flavors meld and it cools just enough to handle. The chicken should be coated in that gorgeous creamy mixture, not swimming in it.

Combine everything:

In a large bowl, mix the orzo with the chicken sauce, then add the eggs, mozzarella, and fresh basil, stirring gently until you can't see any streaks of white—the eggs are what holds this whole thing together.

Fill your cups:

Divide the mixture evenly among the muffin cups, pressing down lightly with the back of a spoon to compact everything without crushing it. You want them snug but not suffocated.

Toast the tops:

Sprinkle panko breadcrumbs over each cup and give them a light mist of olive oil spray so they toast to golden brown and stay crispy. Skip the spray and they'll taste like cardboard.

Bake until golden:

Bake for 18 to 20 minutes, watching for the moment they turn golden and feel set when you touch the top gently. The bottoms should be firm enough to hold their shape when unmolded.

Cool and release:

Let them rest for about 5 minutes so they set properly, then run a thin knife around the edges of each cup and pop them out onto a serving plate. They should come out cleanly without falling apart.

Pin It

What struck me most was how this dish managed to feel like a celebration—fancy enough for guests, simple enough for a Tuesday night, and somehow comforting despite being completely unconventional. These little cups became my answer to 'what do I make when I want to cook something that tastes like I tried harder than I actually did.'

Make-Ahead Magic

The real genius of these cups is that they're completely unbothered by time. You can assemble them in the morning, cover the muffin tin with plastic wrap, and bake them straight from the refrigerator when you're ready—just add a few extra minutes to the baking time since they'll start cold. I've even frozen unbaked cups for up to a month, and they bake beautifully straight from the freezer without any thawing. This means you can do the actual work on your own schedule and have an impressive appetizer ready whenever you need it.

Flavor Customization

While the original version with sun-dried tomatoes and Italian herbs is my go-to, this formula is flexible enough to match whatever's happening in your kitchen or your mood. If you want more heat, double the red pepper flakes and suddenly these feel spicy and bold. If sun-dried tomatoes aren't your thing, swap them for roasted red peppers or even fresh spinach wilted into the cream. The base of creamy sauce, pasta, and chicken is sturdy enough to handle your creativity without falling apart.

Serving & Pairing Ideas

These shine on their own as an appetizer, but they're also perfect alongside a crisp green salad if you want to stretch them further as a light main course. A crisp Pinot Grigio or a light Sauvignon Blanc cuts through the richness beautifully, or pair them with sparkling water and fresh lemon if you're keeping things alcohol-free. Serve them warm or at room temperature—they're honestly good either way, which makes them perfect for parties where timing gets chaotic.

• Garnish with fresh basil and a tiny pinch of fleur de sel just before serving for restaurant-level presentation.
• If you're cooking for people with dietary restrictions, you can substitute gluten-free pasta and panko without changing the result.
• Make these the day before and simply reheat gently in a low oven until warm if you need to reduce morning stress.

Pin It

These little cups taught me that the best food doesn't always come from tradition or complexity—sometimes it comes from asking 'what if I mixed these things together?' and having the courage to actually try it. They've become the appetizer I make when I want to feel proud of something small.

Recipe Questions & Answers

→ Can I substitute orzo with other pasta?

Yes, small pasta shapes like ditalini or small shells work well to maintain a similar texture and bite.

→ How can I add more heat to the dish?

Increasing the amount of crushed red pepper flakes in the sauce will add a pleasant spicy kick.

→ Is it possible to prepare these cups in advance?

You can assemble the cups ahead and refrigerate them unbaked for up to one day before baking.

→ What kind of cheese enhances the flavor?

Parmesan in the sauce and shredded mozzarella on top offer a rich, melty contrast that complements the chicken and herbs.

→ What wine pairs well with these bake cups?

A crisp Pinot Grigio or a light green salad pairs nicely, balancing the creamy richness and herbs.